The Best Agar Agar Substitute For Recipes

If you spend a good amount of time looking up dessert recipes, you’ve probably come across the mysterious ingredients agar agar powder, agar powder or agar flakes. You likely mentally responded with a huge question mark. What is this intriguing ingredient, and do I actually need it in my recipe?

Agar agar powder is essentially a plant-based form of gelatin, so the best way to replace it is to use another type of thickening agent. Since it’s the key ingredient that will decide whether your recipe turns out liquidy or firm, it’s an ingredient that you shouldn’t skip in a recipe.

If you’re reading this, it’s probably because you don’t have any agar powder on hand. If you’re wondering what to replace agar agar with, you’ve come to the right place. Luckily, there are many agar agar substitutes that are easier to find than agar powder.

How to substitute agar agar will largely depend on whether the recipe calls for agar powder or agar flakes. Here is an overview of the best agar agar substitutes:

Cornstarch is the most readily available agar agar powder substitute. In fact, you probably already have some sitting in your cupboard. Since it’s derived from corn grains, cornstarch is also gluten free.

Similar to cornstarch, arrowroot powder is a starch that is extracted from the West Indian Arrowroot plant (Maranta arundinacea). It’s gluten-free and grain-free, making it a paleo-friendly option. Arrowroot is considered to be healthier than cornstarch since it’s produced using more traditional methods and is not linked to corn in any way.

The only downside of using arrowroot powder as a agar substitte is that you’ll need much more of it.

Xanthan gum is another popular substitute for agar agar powder. Unlike starch-based agar substitutes, xanthan gum is basically made from bacterial fermented sugar. Xanthan gum will not harden your recipe in the same way that agar will, but it will thicken it and keep it from separating. It’s commonly referred to as a thickener or stabilizer and is gluten-free.

The only downside of substituting agar agar with xanthan gum is that it’s not as accessible as other agar substitutes. If you’re lucky enough to have a health food store nearby, you might be able to find some there.

Another vegan alternative to agar is tapioca flour, also referred to as tapioca starch or tapioca powder. Tapioca flour is a gluten-free flour made from extracting the starch from cassava root. Since it’s very starchy, it’s comparable to cornstarch in terms of its effectiveness in substituting agar agar. Nonetheless, tapioca flour can be used to replace agar agar in certain recipes.

Pectin powder is one of the best agar agar substitutes, especially if you need to thicken a dessert. Pectin is a plant-based gelatinous-like substance that is made from the pulp and skins of certain fruit. It’s most commonly used as a thickener for jams, jellies, custards, or puddings. Pectin can also be used for preserving fruit.

The only downside of substituting agar agar with pectin powder is that it tends to contain sugar. For that reason, we only recommend substituting agar agar with pectin in dessert recipes.

Agar, also known as agar agar, is a natural plant-based form of gelatin that is usually sold in powder or flake form. When combined with hot liquid, agar powder will thicken. In the vegan culinary world, agar agar is widely considered the best vegan gelatin substitute.

While gelatin that is made from boiling down animal remains, agar agar is derived from certain seaweeds. The main seaweed used to make agar agar is red algae. Red algae are boiled down for hours in order to extract its gelatin-like carbohydrates. The remaining carbohydrates are then dehydrated and sold in various dry forms, such as powder or flakes. Agar agar powder is the most popular form.

Agar powder is commonly asked for in vegan recipes that would otherwise call for gelatin, such as homemade jelly, puddings or even as a soup thickener. Due to its lack of taste, color, odour, and its thickening ability, agar powder is the best vegan gelatin alternative.

When substituting for gelatin in a recipe, agar powder can be used in a 1:1 ratio. In other words, if a recipe asks for 1 tablespoon of gelatin, you can substitute it for 1 tablespoon of agar powder.

Below are some vegan recipes that might call for agar powder: